Does anyone think he contributes?

[Domino]

He doesn't seem to be the best choice on a panel?

[maxi]

I haven't watched it every week, but thought Tim, Chrissie and Paul were good together...

[andole]

Yes, Tim is good on the panel. The only problem is that the show isn't very well structured as it interrupts discussion to often by the host changing the subject. That's why it's hard for panelists to get many comments in without being totally domineering - like that guest they had on last week. He talked over everyone. Paul was terrible in that format, that's probably why he hasn't been back. He was too slow and needed too much time to come up with a retort or comment, by the time he did, the show was on the next topic. But that's what I was critical of above. All of them may have been better if they weren't constantly made to change the subject.

[Domino]

Originally Posted by andole

Yes, Tim is good on the panel. The only problem is that the show isn't very well structured as it interrupts discussion to often by the host changing the subject. That's why it's hard for panelists to get many comments in without being totally domineering - like that guest they had on last week. He talked over everyone. Paul was terrible in that format, that's probably why he hasn't been back. He was too slow and needed too much time to come up with a retort or comment, by the time he did, the show was on the next topic. But that's what I was critical of above. All of them may have been better if they weren't constantly made to change the subject.

I have to agree with you on that andy. I think he has a lot to say and when he does talk it is insightful without being tacky but he is usually talked over or they switch topics too quickly. That guy from BB (02?) just didn't stop talking and neither did the comic although he was a little bit amusing. I wonder why, if it is about BB they don't have more discussion on the actual things that are happening in more depth. Maybe they think we have the attention span of of most of this years HM's. I would like to see Chrissie back, too.

[Peanut]

I reckon they should dump Tony and what's her face and have Tim & Chrissy as the hosts and have a range of past HM on as guests. I loved Nathan in BB2 he has a wicked sense of humor... Does anyone remember him doing the lounge yoga? (I still laugh at that....!!) "and bend and stretch and grab those chips and bend and stretch and grab that beer...." hehehhe

[maxi]

Good call P; Tony and ?? aren't up to it, move them on to infomercials.

[Domino]

Originally Posted by maxi

Good call P; Tony and ?? aren't up to it, move them on to infomercials.

Got to agree...anyone could be better than I cant remember her name either and tony squires...and all she does is sit there with an inane grin and snigger...blech

[Memphis]

I watched my first ep of Big Mouth last week and thought Tim probably contributed the most. Tony Squires is more of a facilitor I guess whilst the ex-HM carry the discussion. But Rachel Wilson, well I'm not sure why she is there.